OtterBox Defender Night Sky Case For iPhone 4/4S 77-18583

Pros: Shock absorbency, color, screen protector.

Cons: The headphone jack is covered for the 4s. If you're a regular headphone user, you'll have to lift a flap to plug in your headphones. This results in un-seating the rubber cover on the front edge after use. This case is also meant to stay on indefinitely. My last Otter case for my 3gs came off easily so I could fit my phone on the dock I use. I've given up trying to use my dock with this phone because the case does not dismantle easily.

Other Thoughts: The belt clip included with this case should come with a pair of suspenders and be labeled with something like "Look at what a huge nerd I am".

Pros: protects case has holster

Cons: big, not nice looking, comes with cheap like screen thing glued to case to protect screen of phone..

Pros: Otterbox quality. Color combo is good.

Cons: Hole for headphones does not light up with actual spot on iPhone 4 or iPhone 4S. The clip on these is a weak point. I go through more Otterbox belt clips than I do the Otterbox protector cases themselves.

Other Thoughts: Otterbox cases do work and will protect your iPhone as well as any on the market. They will break though if you drop them just right, but at least it will save you having to get your phone repaired.