Pros: Well, theres new songs to play in this game, however, the game itself isn't suited towards my age group, and as a result I only know several of the songs...

Cons: Coming from Guitar Hero 3 (and beating TTFAF and TDWDTG on expert AND 4 starring BOTH), and a little bit of Guitar Hero 2, this game is just a re-skinned version of Guitar Hero 3, with new songs, and it features the classic band, Aerosmith.

Other Thoughts: Don't know if this is a pro or con, but there's no option to download songs on XBL. Lastly, I'd just like to add, the few songs I do know are somewhat fun to play... even if it's a whole bunch of new notes to learn >.<

Pros: Graphics are great. Did an awesome job of modeling band members. Like the videos in between career segments. Great song list.

Cons: Dolby Digital encoding is terrible! Sometimes can't even hear the guitar parts. Everything is crystal clear on R.Band. Guitar Hero 3 has the same problem though.

Other Thoughts: This IS Guitar Hero 3 with a modified skin. If you are an Aerosmith fan or just a classic rock fan you'll probably like it. There are some great older songs that I hadn't heard of, but are really cool.