Skip to: |

Newegg.com - A great place to buy computers, computer parts, electronics, software, accessories, and DVDs online. With great prices, fast shipping, and top-rated customer service - once you know, you Newegg.

If you are reading this message, Please click this link to reload this page.(Do not use your browser's "Refresh" button). Please email us if you're running the latest version of your browser and you still see this message.

Newegg.com - Computer Parts, Laptops, Electronics, HDTVs, Digital Cameras and More!

Sign up today for a 30-day free trial of Newegg Premier
  • Shipping Destination: United States
  • Wish List
  • Feedback
  • Help
Search all
Search

Pros:

This is a review for those who are looking to buy inexpensive, low heat, low noise "Eco" drives to use for mass storage. Many of us who have terrabytes of digital media are looking for purely mass depot drives, and not something to dump an OS on. I've run both the Samsung Ecogreen and now the WD Greenpower drives as storage/streaming drives. At 5400 RPM, these drives easily can handle a 1080p/Bluray stream to at least 2 devices.

So, compared to the Samsung Ecogreen 1TB, the WD Greenpower 1TB:

-Definitely runs a few degrees celsius hotter. In my 4 bay raid array, when not in spindown, the WD sits at about 38-39C versus 32-34 for the Samsungs. At idle, with platters spun down, the WD is just 1-2C hotter, a tie for all purposes.

- The WD is as close to silent as you can get. The Samsung Ecogreen have a distinct whirl for spin up and spin down of the drives, and an audible click when first starting up. The WD Greenpower is basically silent, whether it be spin-up, spin-down, or acc

Cons:

I experienced a disk failure in the first day of using my greenpower drives. So my success ratio is:

Samsung Ecogreen 5/5. All drives have run flawlessly
WD Greenpower 4/5. One drive failed in the first day.

It's possibly this was a fluke, but I've got to know down an egg for this.

Other Thoughts:

You can't go wrong with either drive. If low heat is more important to you, go for the Samsung. If low noise is important, go for the WD.

Performance is pretty much as wash between these drives.

Share this review:

7 people found this review helpful. Did you? Yes Yes / No No

  • Dean M.
  • Verified Owner
  • Owned For: 1 day to 1 week


Shop by Region: United States | Canada | China
VeriSign Click for the BBB Business Review of this Computers - Supplies & Parts in Whittier CAThis site protected by Trustwave's Trusted Commerce program Inc500
Policy & Agreement | Privacy Policy  © 2000-2014 Newegg Inc.  All rights reserved.
If the Adobe Reader does not appear when you click on a link for a PDF file, you can download Adobe Reader from the Adobe web site. nassau