Skip to: | | - A great place to buy computers, computer parts, electronics, software, accessories, and DVDs online. With great prices, fast shipping, and top-rated customer service - once you know, you Newegg.

If you are reading this message, Please click this link to reload this page.(Do not use your browser's "Refresh" button). Please email us if you're running the latest version of your browser and you still see this message. - Computer Parts, Laptops, Electronics, HDTVs, Digital Cameras and More!

Home > 
Bart C.'s Profile > 
All Reviews
  • Find Reviews
  • Find

Showing Results: Most Recent

NETGEAR ReadyNAS 516 6-Bay Network Attached Storage Diskless (RN51600)
  • Verified Owner
  • neweggOwned For: 1 month to 1 year

Pros: One point I failed to mention in my other review: The Tool-less hard drive tray.

This tray is real step forward in ease of use. No screws or tools needed to place a drive in, or remove a drive from the tray. An additional and very cool feature is the ability of this tray to also mount 2.5 in HDDs or 2.5 inch SSDs. (2.5 in drives, do need mounting screws.)

Cons: There is a release button that allows the tray to be pulled from the NAS frame. That is the same button that releases the drive from the tray. So if you hold down the release button while pulling the tray out, the drive will separate from the tray. Best to press the release button just long enough for the handle to pop out. Then grab it to remove the tray.

Other Thoughts: Better yet, I just put one mounting screw in each tray just to be sure.

NETGEAR ReadyNAS 516 6-Bay Network Attached Storage Diskless (RN51600)
  • Verified Owner
  • neweggOwned For: 1 month to 1 year

5 out of 5 eggs Evolved for the better 10/18/2013

This review is from: NETGEAR ReadyNAS 516 6-Bay Network Attached Storage Diskless (RN51600)

Pros: I’ve now had several months living with the Netgear 516. And, while my original review of June 1, 2013 (Work in progress . . . at best) was my assessment at the time, I have come around to a more tempered and positive view.

The principle impetus for my new view is the evolution of the OS. (At this writing v6.1.3)

The OS now communicates better with disk status info. Quirks, and dead ends in the UI have been ironed out. And, the connection to the Netgear ReadyCLOUD has been made easier.

All of the original strong points called out in my orig review still stand. Add to that the incredible ability to take “snapshots” of one’s data. I did not fully understand this feature first time around, but this feature alone makes this box a standout. One has the ability to ‘freeze’ or snapshot a data folder on any, user determined, time interval, automatically. This essentially is an automated backup of ongoing data shares. (NB: This is not a real backup, in the sense of a secure copy of data different from the main storage system.) These snapshots give you a time machine to go back to any previous version of one’s data. This is true for folders or individual files. Additionally, one can also schedule actual backups to a separate device, for true backup. This makes the 516 (and others in the family with OS6) a very valuable player in the home office or small business. I have six 3TB drives in mine, and have come to rely on my 516 for data and multimedia storage.

One point that is much better is first start up with new (to the box) disks. The really BIG key is to use disks that have no data on them. If the box senses data on the disks, the mounting of the RAID may fail. The idea is to protect one’s data from inadvertently being wiped. But I consider this false caution. If one is putting disks in a box to mount a new RAID... well you get the idea.

In my original review I raised the question of Netgear’s commitment to the potential of the 516. I see commitment in the evolution of the OS, not so much with hardware. No official memory upgrade (there is an empty slot that could get populated), and no 10 gig add on NIC.

Cons: Of course the hardware issues I wrote about in the orig review remain, I have reluctantly grown accustomed to them (dim display, no power light, etc.) I hope there will be a version two of this box, that incorporates lessons learned.

Having said all the good stuff about snapshots, the bad part is the documentation. It is very thin, and takes a lot of experimentation to get it all set up. There are so-called white papers on the Netgear site, but they really should be called executive summaries, rather than “white papers.” A better approach is to use the product support page and access the KB files. If you read several different KB articles, you can come to a good understanding of the better features of the OS. But, why such a scattered approach?

The UI while much improved from the first version, still has some hidden click points that one has to stumble on, to get hands on all the features.

The app store is thin but growing slowly.

There is no single sign on (SSO). The ReadyCLOUD is one set of credentials, and the app store is yet another.

And, lastly, the RAIDar utility has still not been upgraded to full integration to OS6. Time for a rewrite on this util.

Other Thoughts: I think, in spite of some weak points, the box now earns 5 stars.

NETGEAR ReadyNAS 516 6-Bay Network Attached Storage Diskless (RN51600)
  • Verified Owner
  • neweggOwned For: 1 week to 1 month

2 out of 5 eggs Work in progress... at best 06/01/2013

This review is from: NETGEAR ReadyNAS 516 6-Bay Network Attached Storage Diskless (RN51600)

Pros: Well constructed steel cab, nice new monolith look (but see cons below), 2 bondable 1 gig NICs, provision for expansion, DLNA Server on board, improved web management front-end, eSATA ports, ECC ram, good read write speed over gigabit net (when it works), finally Netgear has solved the noisy fan problem (as heard in other of their NAS boxes), has *potential* for exciting software add-ons.

Cons: re: monolith look - no power-on light... don’t know if it is running or not without hitting the touch panel, drive lights only visible when front door is open (or at a weird angle through the vents), alpha display is small (for the cost of this box), and strangely breaks words at the end of a line, alpha display is fuzzy and dim behind monolith door, touch cursor control is sometimes unresponsive, undocumented behaviors (while setting up) of the new OS6, very poor out of the box setup experience (wrong docs in the box), for the diskless version there is wrong and incomplete setup instructions to populate the box with drives, results of the on board disk test does not match WD drive test utility (it passes drives that the WD util sez are bad), first line tech support rather weak, impossible Chinese puzzle box to get to the RAM slots (there are two slots, only one of which is populated), the OS is on version 6.0.6 and RAIDar (the utility to monitor and setup the box) is not fully compatible, very thin add-on store.

Other Thoughts: The 516 has potential, but will it be fully developed, will the bugs be fixed in a timely fashion? Those are the questions I would put to Netgear. Especially in view of the dramatic abandonment of the ReadyNAS forums, which represent the strongest supporters of these NAS boxes.

As it is, this is a mixed bag box. I have had numerous issues trying to get it up and running with six 3TB Western Digital Reds. I had some bad Red drives and the NAS box seemed unable to report the drive issues... Very poor behavior for a RAID device. This issue is a real deal killer. If the on board disk monitoring is weak, ones data is at risk... The very thing that one buys a RAID box to avoid.


Bart C.'s Profile

Display Name: Bart C.

Date Joined: 12/02/05

  • Reviews: 5
  • Helpfulness: 4
  • First Review: 05/26/13
  • Last Review: 10/18/13
If the Adobe Reader does not appear when you click on a link for a PDF file, you can download Adobe Reader from the Adobe web site.