cover
John K.

John K.

Joined on 03/26/05

0
0

Product Reviews
product reviews
  • 40
Most Favorable Review

Really 4 stars, but the price is great, so 5

NETGEAR 8-Port Gigabit Ethernet Smart Managed Pro Switch (GS108T) - Desktop
NETGEAR 8-Port Gigabit Ethernet Smart Managed Pro Switch (GS108T) - Desktop

Pros: Low cost, lifetime warranty, broad featureset. Set and forget.

Cons: Wall wart. Somewhat irrational web admin interface. Link speed auto-negotiation doesn't always work, and you may need to set a port that links to a slower switch manually.

Overall Review: If you want to play around with vlans, link aggregation, and other bigger-network features, this is great. It's around $80 now, and is a big step up from the lower-cost 8-port switches. It's perfect for small offices that need to segregate their LAN segments.

Most Critical Review

Somewhat clunky, somewhat amazing.

ATT ATT-SB35010 ATT SYN248 ANALOG GATEWAY
ATT ATT-SB35010 ATT SYN248 ANALOG GATEWAY

Pros: Easy to set up, a little complex to use. Not too expensive. A small VOIP PBX that's cheap. It's easier to set up than Asterisk, by a lot. It's easier to set up than an Avaya.

Cons: It doesn't have web-based "operator switchboard" software.

Overall Review: If you have an office that needs a few phones, and you don't have existing telephone wiring, this is a nice little add-on that adds telephones to your LAN. It's a VOIP PBX that uses regular analog phone lines as the outgoing lines. It supports up to four external lines, and something like 12 internal stations. Your call capacity is limited to the number of external lines. It comes with a simple voicemail system. I think the basic use case is an office with an assistant to take calls. If the assistant is gone, it can forward the call to the office. Another common use case is an office intercom system that can hail everyone at once. Yet another use case is an office split across multiple suites that needs a single phone system. The final use case, and to me the most important, is that you don't want business calls going over personal cell phones. All those calls are then potentially either subject to subpoena, or, conversely, you might not be able to get at them in a lawsuit. If you use this PBX, you run calls over POTS and that seems to confer more privacy rights. Also, the logging and accounting features are minimal, so during legal discovery, there's less to analyze, and thus, lower legal costs for you.

Nice balance of power and features.

Buffalo BS-GS2008P 8-Port Gigabit Green Ethernet PoE Web Smart Switch
Buffalo BS-GS2008P 8-Port Gigabit Green Ethernet PoE Web Smart Switch

Pros: Inexpensive, but doesn't feel cheap. Supports VLANs and basic enterprisey features.

Cons: Configuration options are somewhat limited, and the web UI is meh, but it gets the job done.

Overall Review: This is good for a small office where you need to power a few access points over ethernet, and maybe a few desktop switches or cameras. Supports the newer 802.3at devices. If you run a larger network, you should get a switch that integrates with your management software and has a zillion SNMP features. This may not be that switch.

Network gear should look industrial.

ASUS GX-D1081 Power-Saving Gigabit Switch
ASUS GX-D1081 Power-Saving Gigabit Switch

Pros: It functions and is cheap. I can't tell if the special port helps.

Cons: It looks too "toy like", and that turns out to be a problem in offices because people don't realize it's a network switch or something not to be tampered with.

Overall Review: Basically, network equipment should look like an ugly metal box. The plainer, the better. I find that all the metal boxes get left alone, but all the plastic, "designed" stuff gets touched, even abused. People shove them around, stick them behind cabinets, unplug and replug cables, etc. It's very odd. It also happens with routers and access points. Generally, if it looks "official" or like something they wouldn't buy, they won't mess with it too much. If it looks like something from the Apple store, they'll try to mess with it, totally thwarting any effort to do configuration for the device. If it looks "consumer", you might be stuck using only the default settings.

Annoyingly small.

Kingston 8GB DataTraveler SE9 USB 2.0 Flash Drive (DTSE9H/8GBZ)
Kingston 8GB DataTraveler SE9 USB 2.0 Flash Drive (DTSE9H/8GBZ)

Pros: It's small.

Cons: You can lose it.

Overall Review: It's a little too small for me.

The old PC experience.

Cyber Acoustics CA-1001WB 5.25" Drive BAy Amplified Computer Speaker System
Cyber Acoustics CA-1001WB 5.25" Drive BAy Amplified Computer Speaker System

Pros: This brings back the old PC experience of a tower with sound coming out of it. It's nice to have a front-side headphone jack that's high up and not behind some little door.

Cons: See Pros.

Overall Review: If you don't care about sound quality, and don't want audio hitting you in the face, this is ideal. It has a regular, old fashioned volume dial, so you don't need to push buttons up and down as with "digital controls." I don't have the PC anymore, and miss it.