cover
William H.

William H.

Joined on 10/06/08

0
0

Product Reviews
product reviews
  • 38
Most Favorable Review

Wow!

ASUS P6X58D Premium LGA 1366 Intel X58 USB 3.0 ATX Intel Motherboard
ASUS P6X58D Premium LGA 1366 Intel X58 USB 3.0 ATX Intel Motherboard

Pros: I don't think you could ask a motherboard to have anything additional at this price. Four 3-pin fan connectors, two 4-pin fan connectors, heat sinks and heat piping to move the heat across the board, more PCIx slots than I can afford to buy cards for, and a BIOS that lets you go crazy with overclocking. USB 3.0, SATA III, and a reset button on the back to clear the CMOS when you screw up the configuration. It allows you to save multiple configurations and retrieve them as profiles.

Cons: Between every PCIx slot is a PCI slot. If you put a modern Video card in a PCIx slot, you block the PCI slot. So, with this board, if you were to fill up the PCIx slots, you couldn't put any other cards in the chassis. And what else are you going to put into a PCIx slot than a video card.

Most Critical Review

Worthless

HighPoint RocketRAID 620 PCI-Express 2.0 x1 SATA III (6.0Gb/s) Controller Card
HighPoint RocketRAID 620 PCI-Express 2.0 x1 SATA III (6.0Gb/s) Controller Card

Pros: Can't think of any

Cons: If you have an Asus P658D that, you have to either disable the Intel RAID ability or disable the Marvell SATA III controller to even get the machine to boot. Disabling the Marvell controller results in a machine that will go through all of the POST and then hang. Disabling the RAID functionality on the Intel controller lets the system boot. If you enable the RAID and you enable the Marvell, you will not get the BIOS configuration (RocketRaid 1.1) and it will boot and while you can see the controller in Windows 7, you can't see any drives. I'd recommend passing on this card. Waste of money.

Overall Review: I made sure that I had the RocketRaid 1.1 bios, installed the latest Windows 7 drivers, and just cannot get the thing to work. Combo: Intel RAID enabled, Marvell enabled, RocketRaid 620 = boot but cannot see any drives on RocketRaid and never get the BIOS screen. Combo: Intel RAID disabled, Marvell enabled, RocketRaid 620 = boot and can see drives and can configure RAID Combo: Intel RAID enabled, Marvell disabled, RocketRaid 620 = boot but hang after POST Basically, I wanted to have enough SATA ports to have RAID 1 drives for SATA III (hardware Mirror which Marvell 6123 can't do), and RAID 1 SATA II for my other disks. That would be 6 total disks translated into 3 RAID 1 disks. But, add a CDrom and an eSATA and I am out of ports.

Just not reliable

Corsair Force Series GS 2.5" 360GB SATA III Internal Solid State Drive (SSD) CSSD-F360GBGS-BK
Corsair Force Series GS 2.5" 360GB SATA III Internal Solid State Drive (SSD) CSSD-F360GBGS-BK

Pros: When it worked it was nice

Cons: Failed in 2 years

Overall Review: This is my second Corsair Force Series that has failed in less than 3 years of use. Unlike a spinning disk, the Corsair disks fail completely. Loss of everything. I have had Samsung and Plexor SDDs that have lasted longer under heavier load. This one was in a laptop that was powered on only every once in a while so it never exceeded the write cycle of the drive. My main rig is completely Corsair, but I will never buy another Corsair SSD.

Won't boot in UEFI with Asus Z97-Delux

Plextor M6e M.2 2280 512GB PCI-Express 2.0 x2 Internal Solid State Drive (SSD) PX-G512M6e
Plextor M6e M.2 2280 512GB PCI-Express 2.0 x2 Internal Solid State Drive (SSD) PX-G512M6e

Pros: My gosh this thing is lightening fast. It is immediately recognized as a "PCI Express x2" by the Asus Z97-Delux. Go to the Plexor site and download their PlexTool to get more information about the drive once it is installed. Having the SSD right on the board without an expansion card is really convenient. Windows boots in about 8 seconds without fastboot. I had to take off one egg just because of the UEFI boot issue (see cons). Otherwise this would have been a 5 egg item.

Cons: I have tried every setting on the Asus Z97-Delux but I cannot get the system to boot from this drive or even see it during Windows 8.1 installation if I set the system to do UEFI boot only. I have to boot this drive in Legacy MBR mode to be able to see it when installing the OS. I contacted Asus and they said it should work. I contacted Plexor and they said it should work and that they have a similar ASUS board in house that have working perfectly with UEFI. I updated the bios on the Z97 to 1304 (the latest) and the Plexor came with the latest firmware (1.04). But no dice. If anyone has this same drive and motherboard combination and has gotten it to boot from UEFI, please write to indicate what settings you changed in the bios to make it work. The drive works perfectly in Legacy MBR mode, it is just annoying to not be able to figure out the setting to get UEFI. The one thing that may factor in here is that I have the SATA ports setup in RAID mode. The online review on the asus site with the Plexor has the SATA in AHCI. I can't switch to AHCI as I just can't fathom running without the redundancy of RAID on the data drives.

Overall Review: In my previous system that was 5 years old, I went from a spinning boot disk to a SSD. The speedup was impressive. I had a Crucial SSD that died just after the warranty ran out and I had to restore the system to a spinning disk while I waited for a new SSD to arrive. Going back to a spinning disk was torturous and I realized I was really spoiled with the SSD for a boot drive. The old system would take about 30 seconds to boot and be useable. And I never thought about it much. But with this Plexor m6e, I am astounded at how fast the system boots and is completely ready even without fastboot. To Plexor's credit, Plexor did offer an RMA on the drive, but I don't want to pay shipping again on the drive or do without the system during the shipping time.

Solid as a rock

Intel Core i7-4790K - Core i7 4th Gen Devil's Canyon Quad-Core 4.0 GHz LGA 1150 88W Intel HD Graphics 4600 Desktop Processor - BX80646I74790K
Intel Core i7-4790K - Core i7 4th Gen Devil's Canyon Quad-Core 4.0 GHz LGA 1150 88W Intel HD Graphics 4600 Desktop Processor - BX80646I74790K

Pros: I don't see a need for graphics on the CPU, but it came in handy for doing the 48 hour burnin before assembling the entire system. I put this in a Asus Z97-Delux with a Corsair hybrid cooler and it worked flawlessly on first boot. The HDMI on the Z97 let me hook it up to a spare monitor while running cpu and memory tests for burnin. Not an overclocker here so I wouldn't expect any problems.

Cons: None

Overall Review: I have a stack of Intel heatsinks that have never been installed on anything. I wish I could buy the chip alone without a heatsink here on Newegg. But that isn't an option.

Built like a tank

CORSAIR Dominator Platinum 16GB (2 x 8GB) DDR3 2400 (PC3 19200) Desktop Memory Model CMD16GX3M2A2400C10
CORSAIR Dominator Platinum 16GB (2 x 8GB) DDR3 2400 (PC3 19200) Desktop Memory Model CMD16GX3M2A2400C10

Pros: When you pick up the package that holds 2 DIMMs you know this is some quality memory. And I was pleasantly surprised that they have two white LEDs on each DIMM that are shielded behind the silver bar across the fins. So it isn't super bright but you know the chips are properly seated.

Cons: The silver bar over the fins make the memory a bit tall but they still conform to Intel's standard for motherboard profiles. I have an ASUS Z97-Delux that reads the right model number for these chips, but runs them at 1333 instead of 2400. Tuning the board to override so that they are at 2400 had no ill effects. I ran a 24hr memory test with no instability or problems.