Showing Results: Most Recent
Pros: Full capacity seen by Windows. Packaged well.
Cons: Failed out of the box with click-of-death. The read arm was slamming the hdd case so hard it was audible from the outside of the laptop.
Putting the drive in a USB shell and mounting it vertically did not help.
Although Windows recognized the drive it could not be formatted, read from, or written to.
Other Thoughts: There was no shipping or ESD damage, failure was immediate and the controller chip was clearly working.
There must have been mechanical damage done at the factory, which means a quality control problem. This drive should not have been boxed and sold to a retailer.
Pros: Incredibly fast for spinning disk. I regularly get 100MBps even after the SMART failures.
Great value. Don't seem to rely on good shipping packing to arrive in a working state.
Cons: Louder and more vibration than baseline disks.
2 of 2 drives still work fine, although SMART statistics are extremely bad - multiple uncorrectable errors and bad sectors on both drives. One of the drives occasionally doesn't appear in the BIOS, but cold booting brings it back online.
Other Thoughts: I purchased two Toshiba drives to replace these - one of the Toshiba drives was DOA. I purchased two WDC drives to replace the Toshiba drives, and 1 was DOA.
I recommend that, unless buying this model for Price/performance reasons, you avoid 3TB drives. No models from no manufacturer seems reliable. I've had much better luck with 2 or 4TB models.
Pros: Came in retail packaging, 7200RPM, low noise and low heat for the spindle speed.
Cons: I ordered two drives. There was a loud clicking on one right from first power-on. Interestingly, it seemed to work fine for 1 week, and I had no issues until the BIOS refused to recognise it.
I initially thought that the clicking was from a fan, but after the drive lost connection I re-checked and it was definitely the drive head clicking. I'm surprised it worked for that week.
Other Thoughts: The DOA definitely isn't due to NewEgg - the shipping job was top-notch and there was additional foam packing around the retail boxes.
The speeds on these drives is surprisingly low - I noticed no difference in performance from other 5200 RPM "flex speed" drives.