cover
David B.

David B.

Joined on 11/27/03

0
0

Product Reviews
product reviews
  • 5
Most Favorable Review

Great, Stable MOBO for Users Who Don't Overclock

Intel BOXD945PVSLKR LGA 775 Intel 945P ATX Intel Motherboard
Intel BOXD945PVSLKR LGA 775 Intel 945P ATX Intel Motherboard

Pros: Though I'm no motherboard afficionado, I can recommend the D945PVS to everyone interested in an up-to-date, stable, MOBO. The board has a PCI-Express x16 slot for a videocard (no AGP), 4 SATA HD connectors, and lots of included hardware (IDE and SATA cables and a very cool, 3.5" tray, which installs in an external 3.5" drive bay and brings USB, firewire, and audio connectors to the front of your computer case). On-board audio is good and saved me the cost of a sound card. The board comes with an elaborate and informative user's manual. Installing the board was easy, and I also had no problem setting up my new SATA HD using the F6 diskette routine. If you're not into overclocking, you will not go wrong purchasing this board.

Cons: From what others have said, this board should not be purchased by people interested in overclocking. The only serious downside to the board I encountered was its single IDE connector. I don't understand why Intel didn't provide a second IDE controller on this MOBO. Most users have 2 (or more) CD or DVD-ROM drives on their computers and require a second IDE controller for a Zip drive or other internal hardware. To install my computer's IDE hardware, I had to purchase and install a PCI IDE controller card. For those needing only a single IDE controller, however, this MOBO is the bomb.

Overall Review: As always, newegg.com's service was fantastic. I'm glad I don't have to compete against the company's business model: outstanding customer service and excellent prices. I'm sure they'd drive me out of business.

Card performs well; difficult install due to conflic with onboard video chipset

ZOTAC GeForce GT 520 (Fermi) 512MB DDR3 PCI Express x1 Low Profile Ready Graphics Card ZT-50608-10L
ZOTAC GeForce GT 520 (Fermi) 512MB DDR3 PCI Express x1 Low Profile Ready Graphics Card ZT-50608-10L

Pros: Given the limited number of PCe x1 graphic cards that are out there on the market, this card performs very well. I'd purchased the card so my daughter could play Sims 2 on a Dell Optiplex GX520 computer I'd inherited from work. (My daughter told me the Sims 2 images stank on the Optiplex, when compared to those generated by our older Pentium 4 computer, which carried an 8 MB AGP video card.) She tells me the Sims 2 video looks very good with this Zotac board in place. Were we big gamers, I wouldn't have purchased this graphics card in the first place. I would simply have purchased a brand-new PC. However, for those wishing to upgrade an older PC, featuring an isolated PCe x1 upgrade path, this graphics card should fit the ticket.

Cons: I had a devil of a time getting the card to install and work on my Dell Optiplex GX520 mini-tower computer. However, I'm not sure I can blame Zotec or the card for this. Although I repeatedly disabled the motherboard's on-board Intel video through the computer's BIOS, upon booting to Windows, I found that both the Zotac board and the Intel onboard video chipset remained enabled. This produced some type of terrible conflict that resulted in, among other things, blank computer screens, failure to boot to the OS, loss of the Start button and taskbar on my Windows desktop--all of which made me think my computer had been infected by malware, when the symptoms had apparently been caused by the PC's switching back and forth between the Zotac card and the onboard video drivers. If you're having trouble getting this Zotac board to install and work on your PC, try disabling the onboard video found in the "Display Adapters" section of Windows Device Manager. Hopefully that will do the trick.

Great Case, Easy to Work In, With Adequate Built-in Cooling

Cooler Master Praetorian 730 RC-730-KSN1 Black Aluminum ATX Mid Tower Computer Case
Cooler Master Praetorian 730 RC-730-KSN1 Black Aluminum ATX Mid Tower Computer Case

Pros: This case is solidly constructed out of heavy-gauge aluminium. It possesses an aesthetically pleasing design and is a pleasure to look at. The removeable MOBO tray made MOBO installation a snap. Thumb-screw fittings make opening the case and installing add-on cards both toolless and extremely easy. The 120-mm front hard-drive cooling fan and the two 80-mm rear exhaust fans produce acceptable case ventilation and decent system temperatures. (I'm running an Intel Pentium 4 630 CPU on an Intel D945PVS MOBO.)

Cons: Several, none of which seriously detracts from the case's otherwise superb features. First, the black plastic funnel positioned inside the left side window will interfere with the installation of any tall CPU cooler (e.g., a Zalman CNPS9500 heatsink). The funnel, however, can be easily removed. Second, I don't especially like having the USB/audio/Firewire connection panel on the top of the case. (My case sits under a table, making it a pain to access the connectors.) Still, this is just a matter of personal design choice. Finally, the CoolerMaster's MOBO tray did not have a predrilled hole at one of the 11 mounting locations for my D945PVS MOBO. No great hardship since the MOBO's still attached at 10/11 fixation points. However, I always thought MOBO trays possessed mounting holes for every conceivable MOBO configuration.

Overall Review: Anyone in the market for an ATX form-factor computer case will not regret purchasing this one.

12/10/2005

Didn't Cool CPU As Much As I Thought It Would

ZALMAN CNPS9500A-LED 92mm 2 Ball CPU Cooler
ZALMAN CNPS9500A-LED 92mm 2 Ball CPU Cooler

Pros: I use this Zalman unit to cool my Intel Pentium 4 630 3.0 Ghz Prescott CPU (socket 775) on an Intel D945PVS motherboard. I purchased the cooler because people who'd reviewed the 630 CPU on newegg had cautioned against using the stock Intel heatsink. This computer was a new build, so I lack comparison data for what my system's temperatures would have been using the stock cooler. Used Arctic Silver 5 to install. I found installing the unit simple and straightforward. As everyone says, the Zalman cooler's a work of art. Shame I don't get to see it in my windowless PC case.

Cons: After reading so many newegg posts extolling the results achieved with this cooler, I was admittedly disappointed by the degree of cooling I actually achieved on my system. My Pentium 4 630 idles between 39 and 42 C. Under load--and then not an extreme one--the CPU temperature rises to 48 to 52 C. I guess I expected too much. I'd hoped to hit idle temps in the low 30s and load temps in the low 40s with the Zalman. I used slightly more Arctic 5 during the installation than the manufacturer called for. Do you think I applied too little Arctic Silver to the CPU before attaching the heatsink?

Overall Review: As always, newegg got the cooler to me with lightning-fast shipping. One can't beat newegg's customer service!!

12/10/2005

Great/Inexpensive PSU With Minor Problems

Thermaltake TR2 W0070 430W ATX 12V 2.2  Power Supply
Thermaltake TR2 W0070 430W ATX 12V 2.2 Power Supply

Pros: I purchased this PSU largely because of the large number of favorable comments posted on newegg's website. Installation was easy, the sleeved cables are great, and the PSU delivers adequate power to my Intel D945PVS motherboard.

Cons: I can think of only two. The unit I received occasionally emits a high-frequency whine when the computer's on, which can be extremely irritating. Fortunately, it doesn't happen always nor do I wish to imply that this problem is characteristic of the unit. The whine hasn't been continuous and hasn't happened often enough to warrant an RMA. Second, I purchased the PSU before I bought my MOBO, an Intel D945PVS (from newegg, of course). Only on reading the MOBO's owner's manual did I learn that Intel recommends--indeed almost insists upon--using an ATX Version 2.0 PSU for the D945PVS. Only then did I discover that the TR2 W0070 is not an ATX Version 2.0 PSU. It lacks two separate 12 V rails. Notwithstanding this quibble, Thermaltake tech support told me the PSU was "compliant" with the Version 2.0 standard and reassured me that the PSU would not damage my MOBO. I've been using the PSU for a month now to power my system, and the PSU seems to work perfectly fine.

Overall Review: It goes without saying that newegg rocks. I consider the company's prices, shipping, and overall service the best of the best.