Joined on 07/02/08
RAID1 for nearly SIX(6) Years & GOING STRONG
Pros: Have 2 WD RE3 drives in RAID1 in a PC that runs constantly, and they NEVER give any issues. Temps are good, Benchmarks are respectable. The redundancy is for critical data and they DO NOT disappoint.
Cons: None - When I bought these in Jan 2009 they cost more than double current price, but worth EVERY penny; Then and Now!
Overall Review: This review is an UPDATE to one I left nearly 4 years ago, and is just to report that I continue to be amazed at the WD reliability of these drives. I have an older Cosmos 1000 case that is HUGE, but handles the largest Motherboards and GPU's in SLI, and the HDD area is laid out like a server rack, with slide out drawers for the Drives. It has these two WD RE3 1TB drives in RAID 1, and also two Ancient Maxtors in RAID 0 for fast Gaming, and early last year moved the OS Win7 64-bit to a Samsung 840 PRO SSD. These drives are big, inexpensive, and impressive with a proven track record. I always read reviews extensively before purchasing, and hope you find this helpful. Cheers.
Not impressed - Stay Away
Pros: Specifications sounded impressive - problem is that this Caviar Green didn't live up to them. I remain confident in the Caviar Black line of WDC drives, and most especially the RE3's & RE4's. You get what you pay for & this Greenie was low end by comparison.
Cons: Died after 1yr - Only used 3 times as External BackUp - BUT during those few times - the thing seemed to be accessing constantly- and actually sounded busier when in idle.
Overall Review: I was initially impressed at how cool this green hdd ran. Because my system is RAID, I had little need to use external storage, but after only the third use in a year's time, it died. When did it die? The one time I was actually relying on it while I did a system rebuild for a dual boot config. Thankfully, despite ongoing S.M.A.R.T. and Windows 7 warnings, I was able to pull remaining data off before it died stone cold dead. Last chkdsk read an insane number of bad sectors.
Solid as a Rock
Pros: Like the earlier 4/2015 review by Silas, I've used the DX58SO daily for almost 7 years, and it has Never missed a beat. It has run every program and game I've thrown at it over the years, whether for work ... or fun! The onboard RAID is solid and I've run combos of JBOD, RAID 0, and RAID 1 all at the same time - no issues. It has run every video card and SLI combo I could stuff into it and has been a pleasure. I ran a couple of ATI video cards, but the bulk have been nVidia (i.e. GTX295,GTX460x2SLI,GTX760,GTX980 water cooled) The i7 processor has always been water cooled, mildly overclocked, and stable as you can ask for.
Cons: It is hard to poke such a reliable piece of equipment in the eye, but it could have benefitted from more internal SATA ports. I was never able to connect all devices at same time. Not a con of this particular board, but I was extremely disappointed to see Intel exit the motherboard market in 2013. They never made 'EXCITING' boards that appealed to the masses, and that did them in. Intel made solid, reliable hardware. Kind of like comparing a 'Gigabyte, ASUS, etc.' Lexus to a basic 'Intel' Chevrolet - but Hey! I'm a Chevy Man!
Overall Review: For a daily work horse, I'd still recommend this platform to anyone TODAY and for many more years to come, if you can lay hands on a used one. But for more modern and intensive programs (i.e.CAD, video) and newer games, it can't keep up. This review is bascially a sentimental 'so long' to a reliable motherboard that was a breeze to build on, and a pleasure to use. However, after about 7 years, the technology has left it behind. I am moving to the PCIE 3.0, USB 3.1, and other bells and whistles of an X99 Haswell-E system shortly; the next 'Enthusiast' Class Platform since this X58. It's been a good run. Cheers
2Yrs with 2xSLI Setup - Strong
Pros: These cards (have 2 in SLI) run cool (32C idle -> 60C under load) and can deal with anything I throw at them. Also nice & QUIET. I'm more of a BlackOps2, CivilizationV, FarCry gamer, and haven't pushed them with more GPU intense games like Crysis, etc. IMHO no newer GTX has been a big enough leap ahead to upgrade until maybe the latest GTX 700 Series cards coming out now.
Cons: Fan speed is tolerable, but noticeably louder at higher temps (I use MSI Afterburner software to regulate fan speed for optimal cooling). So, consider that if you're willing to tolerate higher temps, the fans will run slower & quieter..
Overall Review: I moved to two of these GTX460's in SLI from a single HD 4870 that was very loud (like a leaf blower) and h-o-t (80-90C with same games mentioned above). Your CASE makes a difference - I run a CoolerMaster Cosmos 1000 (massive) that has 6 - 120mm fans strategically located for good cross ventilation (2-bottom, 2-top, 1-front, 1-rear), and I run a water cooled CPU. It's not silent, but just purrs along. With the old HD4870, I had to use headphones to keep from going deaf/crazy LOL.
Pleasantly Surprised
Pros: Since having a couple of bad experiences with Vista (are there any other kind), I have resistantly clung to XP Pro for dear life. After reading the good reviews and toying with systems running Win7, I decided I should move forward - but I didn't totally let go of the past. I did a clean install into a dual boot configuration with WinXP Pro / Win7 Pro 64bit. Honestly, that was a mistake!!! I should have cut the cord and gone straight over to Win7, since I NEVER find the need to slip back to WinXP. It was a real waste of energy. The boot up & shut down times are phenomenal compared to XP. Some bits are too foo-foo for me but many of the features & 'gadgets' are indispensable . For me, it was a change worth making & I recommend Win7 highly.
Cons: I liked the bare-bones look of WinXP Pro better - I'm a minimalist.
Overall Review: Intel DX58SO Intel i7 920 (not OC'd) 6GB RAM (3x2GB) 2 x ASUS ENGTX 460 1GB - SLI (28-32deg@idle, 45-60deg@full load) Corsair H50 High Performance CPU Cooler (Sealed System) 2 x 1TB WD RE3 HDD - RAID1 2 x 300GB Maxtor HDD - RAID0 Samsung SH-S183L CD/DVDW Samsung SH-S223C CD/DVDW BFG ES-800 PSU APC - NS1050 Back-UPS Cooler Master COSMOS 1000 Case - keeps system chilly Win7 Pro 64bit / WinXP Pro Dual Boot
Rock Solid - Dependable
Pros: Upgraded PSU with first core i7 system and this unit has delivered as promised.
Cons: None
Overall Review: This provides all my power needs for X58 system with 4 HDD's, high-end GPU (haven't tried SLI yet), and multiple burners, etc. I always use an APC UPS as a power conditioner - prolongs the life of any system IMO.