Joined on 03/19/03
Seven Months On, RMA #2
Pros: Still a fast switch, when it works.
Cons: Seven months on and the replacement switch (see review from Dec, 2009) is not working right. Plugging in certain NICs (e.g. NetGear GA311 or anything with an RTL8111 in it) causes all the lights to blink and no pings on any port. Will only link up to a GS108 at 100 Mbps. Will only link up to some NICs at 10 Mbps. Plugging in a Slug (NSLU2) works for a while and then stops (admittedly, it is a competitor's product). Tired of using an FS108 as well as the GS116 to get everything working.
Overall Review: Called Netgear for a second RMA. This time, got a support person who spoke real English and understood networks. No arguments about there being a problem. He opined that it was probably a bad capacitor. Gave me an RMA and we're in business. Fifteen minutes from start to finish with no discernable hold time. Wow! What an improvement in support. Incidentally, I have a GS108 that I replaced the capacitors on, the day I got it. Still working like a champ, after 3 years. Maybe that's the way to go. Maybe Netgear should seriously think about using better capacitors from the get go. Personally, I like Netgear switches but I'm not sure I'd recommend them to someone who wants flawless operation. The lifetime guarantee is still holding, though.
Pros: Looks like an OK product. Your basic Conexant chipset. Easy setup via Web UI. Lots of options. ADSL status page shows everything you'd ever want to know about link status. Small. Unobtrusive.
Cons: After having read the user's manual online, I bought this modem specifically to use as a dumb modem in bridge mode (the docs would appear to imply that this is possible). Despite the fact that there is a "Bridge" setting on the WAN setup menu, and a chart in the docs indicating "Bridge Mode", this modem, per Encore tech support, "was never designed to be setup in bridge mode." So, for me it is a brick.
Overall Review: Docs are, obviously, pretty unhelpful. Long on screen shots but short on explanation.
Best Hardware RAID
Pros: True hardware RAID. Fast, even with write through turned on. Plug it in and it just works. Define an array and it shows up under Linux as /dev/sda. The drivers are built into the kernel. The Linux installer recognizes it and installs right onto it.
Cons: As other people have noted, the UI is pretty clunky. Mind you, once you've set up an array, you'll probably never have to use it again. Also, I could not get the external HD activity light to work no matter what I tried. It just stays on all the time. I wasn't about to flash new firmware into it just for that. 3Ware is now owned by LSI. LSI is now owned by Avago. Who knows how much longer they'll keep selling this line of RAID controllers.
Overall Review: Buy this RAID controller instead of the LSI SAS9240-4i. This one works. The SAS9240-4i is a piece of junk (I know, I've got several of them). Both cards are from LSI but couldn't be more different. Hopefully, when it comes time for the marketing guys at Avago to drop a product line, it won't be the 3Ware RAID controllers because they just work (I've got at least a half dozen of the older ones and they continue to work and work). Its getting harder and harder to plug stuff like this card into Linux and have it work without rebuilding the system. I just migrated a broken Linux from another array. You used to plug in the 3Ware RAID controller, hook up some disks, define an array, copy the previously-installed OS onto it, boot 'er up and away you go. Not any more. I had to reinstall the OS to get the boot partition to work with that abomination that they call a boot loader these days, and then rsync the root partition over. Heaven help you guys who drank the Koolaide and went for ext4 or reiser or LVM. Or no separate boot partition. If that RAID array ever goes south, you're in for it. Lucky for us the 3Ware RAID controllers seem to run forever. Wouldn't it be nice if the hardware guys remembered what the concept of hardware RAID means (you plug it in and it looks like a hard disk)? Wouldn't it be nice if the software guys remembered what plug and play really meant? Instead of plug and reinstall the OS.
Could Be Better
Pros: All the stuff about the 85 chipset is true. It has six SATA ports, including four that run at 6Gb/s. Accepts the LGA 1150 CPUs.
Cons: The biggest con is the lack of a PS-2 mouse port. You'd think, if you were a hardware designer and you absolutely had to use this trick, you'd put the mouse data on the two extra pins of the single port so that one could plug in a simple splitter cable and use both devices. Well, that doesn't work for this mobo. I tried a splitter cable and the mouse still does not work. So, minus one egg for the missing mouse port and then minus one more egg for the missing mouse data pins on the single PS-2 port. Believe it or not, there's still plenty of us who have our 19-inch KVM switches with PS-2 ports and who would like to plug our new mobos into them. On top of that, we don't want to take the performance penalty on mouse movement that occurs with a USB mouse. So, a mobo with both ports is still a plus, or, worst comes to worst, a mobo with a single port that will allow the use of a simple splitter is also a plus to a lesser degree. Now, if you don't care about the PS-2 port issue, you can rate this board five eggs. And, if you do want to use this board with a PS-2 KVM switch, I've found that both the Trendnet TU-PS2 and Perixx PERIPRO-401 PS-2 to USB adapters work with my KVM switch (a Hawking CS-168).
Overall Review: Another mobo manufacturer who could be selling a great mobo for Linux use but is too lazy to certify it for any OS except for the one we're all "supposed" to use, and supply a few basic device drivers. Basically, it works in spite of them. The secret to getting it to work (CentOS 6.5 install comes up and says some piece of hardware [its a secret] is incompatible). The secret? Its the Intel Integrated Grafics. To make it work, under the BIOS Chipset/System Agent Config, make sure to set: RC6 (Render Standby): Disabled; Azalia Internal HDMI Codec: Disabled. Kudos to CentOS for having learned nothing in 35 years and not telling the user which piece of hardware offends, thereby leaving them to guess what it is and how to fix it.
Works With KVM
Pros: Plugs into the USB port of a mobo with only a single keyboard port and UEFI BIOS and then plugs into a PS-2 KVM switch (Hawking CS-168) and away we go. Works without any problems, even when switching back and forth.
Cons: What a feature! Leaving the PS-2 mouse port off the mobo and leaving just a single keyboard port. Pure genius!
Overall Review: If you have a mobo with this latest un-feature, this gizmo will fix the problem. On the other hand, you could just buy a mobo that works....
Partitioning
Pros: Eighty bucks, on sale, for 2TB. Can't beat it. Packaging was much improved over previous shipments (plastic clamshell, bubble wrapped, inside a box, padded with paper, inside a second box). No DOA here. Plugged it in, fired it up, formatted as noted below, started copying files. Easy, peasy. Runs very cool, is quiet and very fast.
Cons: Fdisk took 20 minutes to write 14,000+ inode blocks. Well, whadda ya want? Its a 2TB drive.
Overall Review: Fired up Knoppix on a system with the new disk installed. To partition this advanced format drive, "fdisk /dev/sda", "u", "n", "p", '1", "64", <cr>, "w". This creates a single partition starting at sector 64 and filling the entire disk. Then, to create the file system, "mkfs.ext3 -b 4096 -j -L / -T news /dev/sda1". After I did this, I mounted it with "mount /dev/sda1 /media/sda1" and was away to the races. Copied a boat load of 1.6GB files, using "ncftp -R" from another system over gigabit ethernet. Got consistently 65MB/s and 30s/file which is very, very good. I'd say that this disk is a real performer. Runs extremely cool, even after 20 minutes of this kind of copying. If you're using this drive for video storage, you might want to try "tune2fs -c 0 -i 0 /dev/sda1" to disable fsck on a large file system that never changes (once its loaded). Could be a real time saver on boot.