Pros: When it was alive, it worked great.

Cons: Dead after the third use. No power at all.

Overall Review: Sure, it has a one year warranty, and I'm now going through the RMA process, but it's still a huge annoyance.

Pros: It worked once...

Cons: When I got mine it rattled like nothing was held down inside but it worked the first time The second time it went up in smoke, destroyed a customers hard drive and I just pushed it to the side. It has sat here for two years and I finally took it apart a minute ago to see what happened. The clunking was from a steel plate that was supposed to be attached to the bottom maybe for weight. Since mine had came apart, the steel plate clunked around and got lodged into the power button and shorted many of the contacts out.

Overall Review: DO NOT BUY THIS, if yours makes a clunking sound send a nasty letter to the company. If your warranty has expired open it up and glue the weight down before it causes a fire! I wish I had taken this apart right after I got it, I feel cheated.

I'm a Systems Administrator, I go through docking stations really quick as is, but this has been the worst I have ever purchased.

Pros: Comes with both cables, decent weight, sturdy. Power and activity lights both work.

Recognized all the drives I've used (2.5 inch drives mostly, but a few 1.5's as well.)

Cons: Doesn't come with unicorn tears.

Overall Review: Everything works as advertised, free space for 2.5 inch drives is not an issue - stop complaining.

Pros: Works great and low cost.

Cons: Fools like me who jump to conclusions before testing all possibilities.

Overall Review: I had a bad e-sata port and that was why I thought this was DOA.

Pros: can't tell, it DOA, tried on two separate computers, attaching the same hard drive directly to internal Sata port, they work fine

Cons: DOA, not function on two computers, cable test fine

Pros: NEWEGG is great but this is Not one of their best products.

Cons: Of the three HDDs (all good) I tried I could only see ONE!

Overall Review: I should have read more reviews :-(

Pros: - Good eSATA speed: Getting about 224 MB/s burst, 112 MB/s average with a Samsung 1TB 7200 RPM drive.

- Well-weighted, so it won't fall over with a 3.5" drive in it

Cons: Kingwin's support and QA seems to be minimal. I got 3 of these, and with one of them, the drive activity LED was dead - contacted Kingwin via email and they said they wouldn't fix it.

Also, of the three that I have, the performance varies somewhat. One of them shows a lot of dropouts (speed going to 0) with HDTach... latest one seems to be better.

Overall Review: I haven't used the USB 2.0 port, so I don't know how it performs with that, but it's nice to have as a backup, if I use it with a computer that doesn't have eSATA.

To me, this is a "workman-like" dock... not fancy, but does the job with eSATA. I have one of them with that I have the boot SSD in, because I was too lazy to open up the case.

Pros: cloned a hard drive with no problem

Cons: none yet